City of Hamilton Hockey Borders, News (Ancaster Minor Hockey)

PrintNews Article
Click to view full-size image
City of Hamilton Hockey Borders
Submitted By Tony Valaitis on Thursday, January 11, 2018
The topic of changes to the structure of hockey within the City of Hamilton has been an on-again, off-again conversation between the various Minor Hockey Leagues in the city over the past 13 months. Recently, there have been rumours and speculation in the hockey community in Hamilton, including some media coverage.  We are hoping to answer some of the questions you may have and ask for your feedback.



The topic of changes to the structure of hockey within the City of Hamilton has been an on-again, off-again conversation between the various Minor Hockey Leagues in the city over the past 13 months - as was communicated by our previous AMHL executive board.  Each organization in Hamilton face challenges, some unique - some similar. All are looking for solutions.

In Ancaster, we have held many discussions both as a board and with the broader membership over the past 3 years. Our organization voted on a switch in Member Partner (under the Ontario Hockey Federation - OHF) to the Alliance, and decided to stay with the OMHA where we have operated for 50 years.  Last year, we discussed an amalgamation of our organization with Dundas Minor Hockey, and our membership voted to remain independent.  It has long been the approach of the AMHL to approach potential changes as openly as possible, and with the input of our members.

More recently, there have been a great many rumors and speculation out in the hockey community in Hamilton, including some media coverage.  We are hoping to answer some of the questions you may have as a result of this and ask for your opinions and communications on the subject. 

On December 27th, this article appeared in the Hamilton News. 
 
https://www.hamiltonnews.com/sports-story/8025645-local-minor-hockey-associations-trying-to-solve-boundary-challenges/

We would like to address some of the questions raised by this article as well as some of the rumors out in the community.

In Ancaster, we have taken a bit of a different approach to the issues facing our local associations.  We have some very real concerns about an “open borders” approach across Hamilton - from the geographic “weak spot” Ancaster finds itself in (with both Chedoke and Flamborough offering Double-A rep programs on our doorstep which would likely pull more players OUT of our organization than IN - jeopardizing our ability to field rep teams at each age group), to the potentially negative side-effects that we feel could result  - a weakening of the House League organizations within our communities.

House League needs to be the foundation of any changes that we discuss in Hamilton.  It is the core of our programs, and the roots of our sport.

In this article, the Dundas/Flamborough/Stoney Creek/Huskies organizations were quoted pointing out the inflexibility of the current geographic boundaries.  Moving an organization from the OMHA to the Alliance does not address these issues. Both the OMHA and Alliance have made it clear that geographic boundaries exist under both organizations.

The importance of House League and the effect that some of these changes may have on our Local League teams was not touched on in this article. Opening up the borders between associations may have the unfortunate result of seeing more Rep Teams assembled out of the same (declining) number of players - that does not make good sense, or end up with a better outcome.  We are all for our players playing at the Rep level, but only where that level is up to the level of the competition. If we field a team “just because” we risk that team not competing and the players losing their passion for the game. As was pointed out in the article, our local girls associations do not have these boundaries to stop player movement.

What was missed in this article was the House League impact of this freedom. Many of the age divisions in the girls associations are running with two, or maybe three House League teams in each community - and 3 or 4 Rep Teams.  This equates to an inter-lock House League schedule with Ancaster girls playing house league games in St. Catharines, Port Colborne, and Haldimand. This would not be the desired outcome of this “no border” change, in our opinion. Having our kids spend more time in the car going to and from games and practices does not seem like a good use of their time, good for their development, or very enticing to “would be” parents in our community.

We don’t need MORE rep teams in Hamilton.  We don’t have the open, available ice in Hamilton to support the additional ice needs that this would bring.  We need to make hockey more accessible, community focused, and FUN.  

In Ancaster, we have held discussions with our neighboring associations - Flamborough and Dundas to look into the possibility of working together in a slightly larger geographic area to address issues facing both Rep and eventually House League scheduling.  We would be open to this conversation with any of our neighboring OMHA associations. In our vision, the City of Hamilton needs fewer organizations (rather than the current 12 or 13) to be able to field competitive, TRUE Rep Teams and a healthy and vibrant House League program.  

This past weekend, members of our executive attended a meeting in Flamborough with representatives from each of the local Hockey organizations in Hamilton, the City of Hamilton, as well as the OMHA and Alliance.  We discussed the issues facing each of our organizations, and looked for common threads.   At the root of these discussions, we are looking to build strong Hockey communities that can support the next 50 years of hockey in Hamilton. The AMHL is a special and vibrant hockey community - we have a great many strengths that need to be celebrated and encouraged.

It is only with the support and input of our membership that we will continue to thrive - and I ask anyone that would like to give their input (or ask questions) on these subjects to email me directly at [email protected].   

See you at the rink!

Paul Empringham
AMHL President



This article has been viewed 801 times.
Category Sites
League Sites
Social Networking
Follow Us On
Visit Ancaster Minor Hockey on Facebook
Quick Links
Manage Subscriptions
Signup to receive email or text messages for the teams you want to follow.
News ArchiveOther Recent Articles
  • 30
    Dec
    Organization
    The Major Midgets won the Silver Stick Regional tournament held in Brampton December 28-30, 2107. They now move on the Silver Stick International tournament in Sarnia on January 12-14.
  • 17
    Dec
    Organization
    The Major Peewee A team made a generous donation of toys and games to the McMaster Children's Hospital on December 16, 2017. 
  • 13
    Dec
    Organization
    On Sunday December 10th, the Ancaster Minor Atom A Team gathered items for "Give Where You Live" with a Team coordinated holiday donations drive. The team accumulated a Truckload of items consisting of food, clothing, toys and gift cards for ...
  • 08
    Dec
    Organization
    In the spirit of Christmas giving, The Major Peewee AE team coordinated a community Charity Bottle Drive on Saturday, December 2, 2017 and raised a total of $1,885 for MacKids & Mission Services.
  • 27
    Nov
    Organization
    The Novice "A" team captured gold at the Canadian Tire Classic in Barrie the weekend of November 24-26, 2017. 
  • 16
    Nov
    Organization
    The Minor Atom A team battled hard to bring home Silver in the 34th Annual AA Tournament Of Champions, in Stoney Creek Nov 9 - 12, 2017.  The boys won 2 of their 3 games in the round robin play, allowing only 2 goals and scoring an impressive 8. 
  • 13
    Nov
    Organization
    The very resilient Major Peewee AE team captured gold at the Jim Wilson Chevrolet Buick GMC Winter Classic (Orillia) the weekend of Nov 10-12, 2017. This is their third straight tournament win this season, which puts them in pretty elite company in ...
  • 07
    Nov
    Organization
    Congratulations to the Ancaster Avalanche Minor Peewee A Team who took the Silver Medal home from the Peter Mancuso November Challenge November 3-5, 2017 in Niagara Falls!
Printed from ancasterminorhockey.com on Saturday, January 20, 2018 at 12:24 AM